This report provides a series of biogas solutions for New York’s greater Hudson Valley while addressing four significant categories of need;
A) managing excess food waste according to legislation mandates,
B) restoring ecosystems overburdened with the invasive aquatic water chestnut,
C) achieving NY’s CLCPA renewable initiatives aimed to mitigate climate change, and
D) catalyzing environmental justice efforts to revitalize our impoverished communities.
Through these four perspectives, the proposed installations can help the region accomplish its economic development goals in an environmentally just manner while setting the necessary foundations for scaling related infrastructure. System solutions will invite additional innovation to the area and create a hub for education and information exchange. Investments in these technologies are paramount for long-term community growth, increasing workforce skills, and proliferating green jobs. With this strategy, the public can engage with many regional stakeholders, and welcome a unified pathway for sustainability.
In April 2019, New York State (NYS) legislators passed the NYS Food Donation and Food Scraps Recycling Law which requires large generators of food scraps (more than 2 tons per week, on average) to redirect this biomass for beneficial use. Diversion of this waste stream should follow the EPA’s Food Recovery Hierarchy and, if suitable, first be donated to food banks, soup kitchens, and shelters. If the food is expired and pre-consumer, it should be added to animal feed (EPA Wasted Food Report, 2018). If it doesn’t meet regulations for these two categories, it must be diverted to organic recycling as long as there is a facility within 25-miles of the point of origin. Anaerobic digestion falls within the EPA’s next hierarchical category of ‘industrial uses,’ and the NY legislation specifically includes ‘organics recycling on-site via in vessel anaerobic digestion’ as an acceptable method of managing this waste (NYS Food Law, 2019). Therefore, this law presents an opportunity to apply localized biogas production throughout the Hudson Valley as a means to meet these stipulations. This solution eliminates a significant portion of otherwise necessary transport activity while conserving the food’s inherent energy and nutrients within the local economy. In this way, these compounds can be recycled into the local ecosystem and shared throughout communities.
NYS has been exposed to many invasive plant species which have negatively impacted water ecosystems along with recreation and tourism. Water chestnut, or Trapa natans (FIGURE A), is native to Eurasia and Africa and was introduced into the US in the mid-1800s as an ornamental plant. Today, the NYS DEC has recorded its presence in 42 out of 62 counties throughout the state. This plant thrives in freshwater lakes, ponds, slow-moving streams, and rivers by establishing a long root network that anchors to the bottom of the waterbody (DEC, Water Chestnut). Each year, public taxes help fund management and removal efforts to temporarily reclaim some water access for recreational use and local biodiversity. Unfortunately, these actions have not been able to mitigate the plant’s prevalence as it continues to overburden priority water bodies (DEC Invasive, 2018).
Anaerobic digestion offers an innovative solution to this problem by utilizing Trapas natans as a feedstock for biogas production. This alternative management concept for the Hudson Valley can serve as an economic driver for ecosystem restoration efforts while offering a renewable and energy efficient installation. According to the American Biogas Council (ABC), this species produces almost 50% more methane than cow manure. In addition, the process extracts excess phosphorus and nitrogen compounds which have eutrophied the Hudson River watershed and compounded this species' overgrowth. These nutrients can be returned to the agricultural sector and simultaneously create a pathway for biodiversity recovery by permitting the restoration of native plants and rehabilitating the river’s dissolved oxygen levels.
Energy discussions in NYS have become focused around climate change mitigation strategies as representatives and activists make substantial efforts to reduce dependencies on fossil fuels and implement new renewable sources. In 2019, the NYS Legislature passed the Climate Leadership and Community Protection Act (CLCPA, or ‘Climate Act’) which introduced an aggressive climate change mitigation agenda. The declared objectives include an 85% reduction in greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by 2050 (relative to 1990 levels), 100% carbon-free electricity by 2040, 70% renewable energy by 2030, and a reduction in 22 million tons of carbon through energy efficiency and electrification (NYS CLCPA 2019). These Hudson Valley Circular Biogas System proposals seek to meet this ambitious challenge through avoiding current transportation and landfilled emissions, producing renewable energy, and sequestering carbon.
New York Independent System Operator (NYISO) reports that nearly 90% of the energy produced in the upstate region north and west of the capital is already derived from carbon-free resources while in downstate regions, this portion only represents about 30% (NYISO, 2019). Therefore, these biogas solutions actively address climate action throughout the greater Hudson Valley where mitigation efforts matter most. In addition, bioenergy serves a primary role in the IPCC’s 1.5°C emission reduction pathway. Thus, these circular systems also align with international strategies to reduce anthropogenic emissions and facilitate a green energy shift.
The burdens of inequality, environmental hazards, and income disparity have affected many demographics across NYS. In response, the CLCPA has also established a Climate Justice Working Group to help identify disadvantaged areas and take action to repair and revitalize these respective communities. Under this legislation, environmental justice regions will be allocated at least 35% of the benefits associated with NY’s clean energy and efficiency initiatives. An Environmental Justice Advisory Group is set to advise state agencies on how to embed this target goal into decision making while a corresponding Just Transition Group will prepare a comprehensive workforce development program. The Hudson Valley Circular System proposals are presented with consideration for this important factor and will help facilitate NY’s commitment to this goal. The region of focus covers approximately 7,700 mi² (~20,000 km), and is home to over 2.6 million people, and spans 11 counties north of NYC; Albany, Columbia, Dutchess, Delaware, Greene, Orange, Rockland, Putnam, Sullivan, Ulster, and Westchester. Each proposal is nearby or within an identified environmental justice area, and these installations prescribe a series of roadmaps that inject investment capital into these communities. By aligning with key stakeholders, Hudson Valley Biogas is pursuing meaningful treatment of all people, regardless of race, income, national origin or color and maximizing these efforts with respect to the development, implementation, and enforcement of environmental laws, regulations and policies.
The NY Regional Economic Development Councils promotes ‘WORK, LIVE, PLAY’ as part of their marketing strategy for economic competitiveness and long-lasting growth. Each of the 10 proposals invite opportunities for additional infrastructure expansion and growth with community residents and new technologies. Training from the manufacturers is included with equipment installations and offers an attractive opportunity for unskilled workers to participate in on-the-job learning. This method of implementation fosters a bridge with education and skill development that can be guided with the help of local institutions and learning centers.
Hudson Valley Biogas meets the WORK strategy through diversification of green jobs that are required to continuously grow with the success of communities. While many of NY’s renewable energy initiatives related to installation of green infrastructure only create temporary jobs, these 10 proposals each generate long-term work requirements. This form of job security is necessary in order to achieve measurable economic development that can withstand the tests of time such as unexpected downturns and depressions in the local economy.
The LIVE strategy is met by creating centralized resource and recovery operations that can be scaled with a variety of add-on technologies. In this way, the locations will evolve into innovation hubs that breed even more resilient ideas and sustainable practices. Installations can become key destinations for community engagement with integration of agriculture and food security. Learning the most effective and responsible ways to manage human waste streams is paramount to understanding the ecological balance and system designs of mother nature.
The PLAY strategy is achieved through the processes that help to restore and cleanse the local ecosystem. Incorporating the invasive aquatic water chestnut as a feedstock into the production cycle creates an economic incentive to clean and restore priority water bodies. Reclaiming these spaces is critical to health and recreation as people seek to be more in touch with the environment. Clean and safe areas will invite tourism and related commercial developments into once deprived areas. Circular solutions are the foundation for all of these aspects and activities.
The proposed installations can help the region accomplish its economic development goals in an environmentally just manner while setting the necessary foundations for scaling related infrastructure. Investments in these technologies are paramount for long-term community growth, increasing workforce skills, and proliferating green jobs. With this strategy, the public can engage with many regional stakeholders, and welcome a unified pathway for sustainability.
Biogas production has the potential to evolve into an environmentally beneficial and economically viable industry in New York State’s lower Hudson Valley. This form of renewable energy infrastructure is complementary to the state’s climate change mitigation goals, and new low carbon fuel standards have created profitable incentives for the construction and operation of anaerobic digesters (AD). This study aims to identify, collect and collate quantitative and qualitative data on available biogas feedstocks inclusive of excess food waste, biosolids, animal manure, landfills, biocrops (crops grown specifically for AD), invasive species, and compost. The area of focus spans 10 counties, between New York City and Albany, which covers approximately 7,200 mi² and is home to over 2.3 million people; Columbia, Dutchess, Delaware, Greene, Orange, Rockland, Putnam, Sullivan, Ulster, and Westchester. By mapping the availability of these bioresources, corporations and policy makers can use this data as a foundation for designing and implementing an integrated bioenergy system throughout the Hudson Valley.
This report offers 10 circular biogas production system designs for the greater Hudson Valley which covers an area extending from the northern limits of NYC and up through the capital district. These investments are necessary for long-term growth, increasing the workforce skills of citizens, and facilitating sustainable solutions for the greater Hudson Valley. Each integrated technological design offers innovative solutions that are iconic representations of circular production systems and treat available resources as high value materials for a regenerative production cycle; reuse, repair, refurbishment, remanufacturing, and recycling. Overall, this initiative will help NYS transition from its outdated linear business practices to more sustainable solutions that align with current legislative initiatives and meet the evolving and necessary demands of a low-carbon future. Each component plays an indicative and strategic role in the greater mission of achieving international sustainability, and these precedents can be scaled and replicated across the state, country, and world to truly empower the people, planet, and prosperity.
Hudson Valley Biogas' initial feedstock assessment and the resulting 10 Circular System Proposals have begun to write the next chapter of this region’s environmental movement. Everyone can share in these initiatives and unite around a common goal of a responsible society. Become part of this movement and learn to live, serve, and maintain the beauty of the Hudson River Valley.
Just as the Hudson Valley gave birth to the modern American environmental movement in the 1960s, we are again positioned to design a system of prosperity and sustainability to inspire the nation. With renewable energies as the primary focus for the future, we have the opportunity to consider new and innovative technologies that will propel and encourage others for generations to come. We can join together and share promises of hope, love, and security for the future. May you be inspired.
“Kunnskap for en bedre verden” - “Knowledge for a better world” - NTNU